Tether S&P stability score stays at 5 as risk assets hit 28%
S&P Global kept USDT at 5 (weak) after higher-risk assets rose to 28% of reserves, while Tether argued the rating framework is the problem, not its balance sheet.

In this article
Editor’s take (Keshav Aggarwal): I don’t see a trust issue arising for USDT because it is a stablecoin, and I believe this is good for holders. On what comes next, my view is that the US have to wait.
S&P Global Ratings held the Tether S&P stability score at 5 (weak) on Nov. 18, the bottom of its five-point scale, after finding that assets it classes as higher risk equaled 28% of USDT in circulation as of Sept. 30, up from 24% a year earlier. Tether rejected the finding, telling Cointelegraph that “the problem is S&P’s framework, not our reserves.”
The assessment measures a stablecoin’s ability to hold its dollar peg and is not a credit rating. S&P made no downward adjustment this year, noting in the report that its view “cannot be lower than 5” — USDT was already sitting on the floor.
What the Tether S&P stability score does and does not measure
The score is a peg-risk opinion, not a judgment on Tether’s solvency or a formal rating of the issuer. It weighs the quality and liquidity of the assets backing a token and how those assets would behave in a stress event.
S&P’s central warning is conditional: “A significant drop in the value of these assets could lead to USDT being undercollateralized.” Its higher-risk bucket includes gold, bitcoin, publicly traded equities, corporate bonds and secured loans — exposures sensitive to market prices, interest rates and borrower creditworthiness.
The agency also flagged that higher-risk holdings substantially exceed Tether’s available reserve surplus. On the reported figures — 28% of roughly $183.5 billion in Sept. 30 liabilities — that implies about $51 billion of higher-risk assets against a $7.95 billion excess buffer, which is the arithmetic behind the Tether S&P stability score.
Gold up, bitcoin down, equities added: Tether S&P stability score inputs
S&P documented a shift in the reserve mix over the year, with a reduction in bitcoin offset by larger allocations elsewhere. Tether’s own attestation, signed by BDO Italia, put assets at $191.45 billion against $183.50 billion in liabilities at the end of September, a collateralization ratio of 104.3%.
| Reserve component | Sept. 2025 | Sept. 2026 |
|---|---|---|
| Gold | $12.9B | ~$19B |
| Bitcoin | $9.9B | $8.4B |
| Public equity investments | — | $4.2B |
| Total assets (BDO Italia) | — | $191.45B |
| Total liabilities | — | $183.50B |
The excess reserve buffer nearly doubled from $4.11 billion at the end of June to $7.95 billion at the end of September, alongside quarterly net operating profit of $1.5 billion, according to crypto.news. Tether’s direct and indirect exposure to U.S. Treasury bills stood at $132.4 billion, and T-bills and reverse repurchase agreements generate most of its operating income.
The transparency dispute behind the Tether S&P stability score
Reserve disclosure is the second front. In August, Tether said it had completed its first full independent audit, with KPMG U.S. issuing an unqualified opinion on its financial statements for the year ended Dec. 31, 2025. Tether said the auditor physically inspected and counted every gold bar it holds.
S&P said the audited statements, notes and auditor’s report have not been made public, limiting its ability to examine the underlying information. It also noted that quarterly reserve reports do not identify custodians, banking partners or counterparties, and that disclosure on the composition and credit quality of secured loans and corporate bonds remains insufficient. Attestations are quarterly, while S&P notes other stablecoins generally report monthly. That disclosure gap is a main reason the Tether S&P stability score remains at the floor.
Regulatory scope adds to the gap. Tether relocated from the British Virgin Islands to El Salvador in 2025 and operates under the National Commission of Digital Assets, which requires at least one dollar of reserve assets per dollar issued and at least 70% of reserves in assets liquidatable within 30 days. S&P considers that framework looser than U.S. and European counterparts because it permits bitcoin, gold and loans without requiring reserve segregation — leaving, in its view, insufficient public information on how reserves would be shielded from issuer insolvency or losses elsewhere in Tether’s businesses, which include artificial intelligence and bitcoin mining.
Tether S&P stability score: the company’s rebuttal
Tether’s response leaned on the ratings agencies’ record. “Their own history shows the underlying problem,” the company told Cointelegraph, invoking the 2008 financial crisis and its depiction in The Big Short. Chief executive Paolo Ardoino made a similar argument when S&P first cut USDT from 4 to 5 in November 2025, writing that “we wear your loathing with pride.”
The issuer maintains that its non-stablecoin operations are managed separately from USDT’s reserves. It also points to a point S&P concedes: the agency acknowledged USDT’s history of holding its dollar peg, particularly over the past 12 months.
Market check: a live stress test for the Tether S&P stability score
The debate is running against a weak tape. Total crypto market cap stood at $2.28 trillion at 09:20 UTC on Nov. 19, down 0.95% in 24 hours, with the Crypto Fear & Greed Index at 10 (extreme fear), per Alternative.me — the kind of drawdown S&P says could test collateral. Bitcoin traded at $63,773, down 13.16% over seven days and 49.52% below its all-time high of $126,173, while ether was 26.48% lower over 30 days.
USDT itself showed no strain in the data. CoinPaprika put it at $0.99933, a fraction of a cent below par, with a $175.13 billion market cap and $48.29 billion in 24-hour volume — more turnover than bitcoin’s $21.57 billion. For scale, USDC, the second-largest stablecoin, carries a $68.26 billion market cap.
What to watch next for the Tether S&P stability score
- The next attestation. Tether’s quarterly reports will show whether the 28% higher-risk share keeps climbing after the recent slide in bitcoin and equities, or whether the buffer absorbs it.
- Publication pressure. S&P’s criticism narrows to disclosure. Publishing the KPMG opinion, naming custodians or moving to monthly reporting would remove its stated blind spots without changing the reserve mix.
- Regulatory reaction. U.S. and European stablecoin regimes require segregation that El Salvador’s framework does not, and a weak third-party score is an easy reference point for supervisors weighing cross-border access.
- Redemption mechanics. Direct redemptions stay limited to verified customers holding at least $100,000 in tokens, with a $150 verification charge and a $1 redemption fee, per crypto.news — terms that matter most if secondary-market liquidity thins.
S&P’s score is best read as a warning about what a severe drawdown could do to a reserve base with a growing market-sensitive sleeve, not a finding that USDT is broken today. Tether’s rebuttal — that the framework is too blunt — is a fair critique of a five-point scale with a floor, but it does not answer the disclosure questions S&P keeps raising.
Frequently asked questions
What is the Tether S&P stability score?
It is S&P Global Ratings' assessment of a stablecoin's ability to maintain its dollar peg, scored on a five-point scale where 5 is the weakest. It is not a credit rating. S&P held USDT at 5 on Nov. 18, unchanged from November 2025.
Why did S&P keep USDT at the lowest score?
S&P said assets it classes as higher risk — gold, bitcoin, public equities, corporate bonds and secured loans — equaled 28% of USDT in circulation as of Sept. 30, up from 24% a year earlier, and warned a sharp drop in their value could leave USDT undercollateralized.
Is USDT still fully backed?
Tether's Sept. 30 attestation from BDO Italia showed $191.45 billion in assets against $183.50 billion in liabilities, a 104.3% collateralization ratio and a $7.95 billion surplus. S&P's concern is that the higher-risk portion of those assets is larger than that surplus.
Sources: crypto.news, Cointelegraph




